There was also a lack of a blood trail or footprints leading outside of the garage. Granted, I think the earlier programs were slanted more towards her guilt than innocence. And, the problem with this fitting the Darlie supporter's black car theory is that the car Sally reported was white. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Bedrooms: 3. She told Officer David Waddell that she fought with the intruder at the end of the kitchen bar (facing the family room), She told Officer Matt Walling she fought with the intruder at the couch while she was still laying on it, In her formal written statement to police, dated June 6. Why would she do that? As mentioned previously, Darlie had contemplated suicide a month before the murders and had written about it in her diary. Hi Magpie 9, good to hear from you again! On November 14, the court announced jury selection was complete and it would consist of seven women and five men. She's in Canada and that last comment originated in the Philadelphia area. Both officers testified that it was not on when they initially checked the garage and backyard. "My life has been such a hard fight for a long time and I just can't find the strength to keep fighting anymore." (I live out in the country) He barks at everything at night, possums, squirrels, raccoons, skunks, deer; you name it, he barks at it. The physical evidence investigators examined that area and determined that there had been significant quantities of blood shed immediately in front of the sink. Typically amusing, but not at all surprising. Doug Mulder: Okay. SClemmons- "It is all in how you tell your story.just tell the story right". They'll quote a question and answer from witness testimony that relates to their point, but won't print all that followed in that testimony during a prosecutorial line of questioning. The only blood discovered in the utility room, (Which led to the garage) was found on the edge of the utility room door and in two separate places on the left side of the washing machine; it was identified as belonging to Darlie. When he started crying she told him he deserved it. They did observe an open window in the garage close to the floor with a vertical cut to the screen. Now maybe I am just cynical, but I have never seen someone call themself a "career criminal" who goes around revisiting old cases online trying to get somebody else thrown in jail. She had all the time in the world prior to dialing 911 to stage the scene at the house, stab the boys, and walk the sock down the alley in an attempt to confuse police and draw attention away from herself. The same thing happens on the Darlie support sites, I've been literally roasted on a few support sites for expressing my belief in Darlie's guilt. At two minutes and two seconds into the call. It's also important to note that insurance records on the boys and her handwritten will were found at the foot of the couch by investigators. Only Jackie Lynnley, Pollyann, and that moron with more names than she has years of formal education keep repeating this MYTH about her being drugged because it is made up out of THIN AIR. She also testified to this while on the witness stand during the trial. The children were murdered in June 1996, and Routier . She didn't definitively say it was or wasn't self inflicted despite Defense attorney Doug Mulder's attempts at getting her to rule out self-infliction on the witness stand. Nabors noticed Darlie's purse and the many gold rings and bracelets (Including a Rolex watch) she had worn that day sitting on the kitchen counter where she had taken them off before lying down on the couch. James Cron found it odd that other than a blood smudge on the door leading to the utility room and two blood smudges on the side of the washing machine, there was nothing else past that point to indicate that an intruder had exited through the garage as Darlie had claimed; not one drop of blood anywhere. This has yet to happen. It is just so arbitrary. Darlie Routier: I put a towel on Damon's back. On May 23, 1996, they received a notice of foreclosure on their house (Barbara Davis, Precious Angels, pg. He told the media in a press conference that he was going to make it his "Mission in life" to find the killer(s) of his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman. Her third appeal has moved to the federal level with the U.S. District Court in San Antonio, which is her last option. Darlie supporters are quick to say this is how Damon and Devon's blood got on her nightshirt. After a decade many of the DNA has never been tested. Darlie even said in her initial written statement to police that she screamed for Darin and he was there before she called 911, "I looked over and saw the door shut to the garage, and so I thought he might still be in there, and I needed to get Darin. Asst. I just read it for a second time. Darlie Routier was booked at the Rowlett City Jail and arraigned by Municipal Court Judge Owen Lokken. Prosecution: Are you sure that she didn't tell you that the struggle occurred between the kitchen and the family room? Let me know your thoughts about the episode. Who's to say that nick wasn't in the chain when she purchased it? I don't get on those Facebook groups much. I'll have to see if I can locate the week it was published, may take a little "time." Real Name: Darlie Lynn Routier Case: Appeal Location: Rowlett, Texas Date: June 6, 1996 Case Details: Darlie and Darin Routier were married with three sons. Prosecutors don't need to have a motive to prove someone committed murder, they only have to prove the accused did it. Sclemmons, if "Nightmare324" writes at that level, he CANNOT POSSIBLY be able to read this article and even understand it unaided, so don't even acknowledge this ridiculous criticism. Despite Pardo's efforts, Spence was executed in 1997. On June 6, 1996, at 2:31 am, the emergency communications center (911) in Rowlett, Texas received a call from a private residence in the upscale Dalrock Heights subdivision owned by 28 year old Darin Routier and his 26 year old wife, Darlie. So much of your article was extremely difficult and heart-wrenching for me to read. Greg Davis and Toby Shook, The Defense. These new test results utilizing new and improved technology as opposed to 1996 technology, just all the more confirmed Darlie Routier's guilt. SClemmons (author) from the Carolina Coast on October 12, 2018: Thank you Paula for your comments and your gracious insight. Lieutenant Grant Jack, commander of the Rowlett Police Department's Investigative Division, was summoned at home and arrived on the scene around 3 AM. *Each of these drugs cause bad "hang-over" signs and symptoms which Darlie never complained to anyone that she had. Waddel testified that he immediately looked in the door of the garage when he arrived and there were no lights on in the garage or the back yard. But when asked to support these claims with provable fact, the Darlie supporters just can't do it. The blood on the towel was Darlie's, and no water was found on the towel. Darlie is right handed. We DON'T have to be physically there to know, it's called INVESTIGATION!!! Darlie just didn't possess the smarts to have planned this ahead of time. luo xiao min from California on August 09, 2018: Wanttobelieve, with all due respect (i really mean it). There was one physician, Dr. Santos conducting the procedure accompanied by a resident (doctor in training) who was observing. I wholeheartedly agree with the guilty verdict. This was confirmed by Darlie's attorney, Stephan Cooper. Tests revealed that it would stay on for 18 minutes after it was activated. Some of the most commonly prescribed meds included: fluoxetine (Prozac), sertraline (Zoloft), Paroxetine (Paxil), citalopram (Celexa), escitalopram (Lexapro) and fluvoxamine (Luvox). The Luminol application to the kitchen area showed that a significant amount of blood had been rinsed down the drain most likely with the sprayer. Jimmy Patterson in more recent years. He had been sitting in his police cruiser in a church parking lot doing paperwork just a few blocks away. The mother, Darlie, clutched a wet bloody towel to her neck and was standing near him on the phone. On November 15, 1996 (about 2 months before the trial) prosecutors publicly suggested that Darin might have helped Darlie stage the crime scene to mislead investigators. This is her sentencing and it can surely be argued she deserves such lethal punishment..I am of the belief that natural life in prison w/o the possibility of parole (especially because it is Darlie) would be a far worse price for her to pay. On a very personal note, I am not completely in favor of the death penalty. The vacuum cleaner in the kitchen with blood underneath it. (2 days after the murders) Darlie claimed that she put a towel on Damons back. Paramedic Jack Kolbye, the paramedic that tended to Damon in the house was called to testify. She further said if she hadn't put her arm up, he would have killed her. It showed wiped up blood from the counter, the cabinet doors, and on the sides of the sink. Just letting you know ABC doing a program on Darlie on June 12th, hosted by Viola Davis and her husband and titled "the last defense" Darin will be making an appearance on this program. But, despite your typical Darlie supporter bitterness and attempts at insulting someone who opposes your views, Im going to break my own rules and answer your questions regarding what you call, the absurdity of my article. A green and white washcloth in the kitchen area is the one Officer Waddell observed Darlie holding to her neck when he first entered the house. Dr. Santos: Yes. "It would be downright entertaining if it didn't take away so much time from what I need to be doing--researching and writing the appellate brief. Darlie supporters love to direct people to an old CBS 20/20 special taped 18 years ago in 1999, hosted by moderator Sylvia Chase. I am so very happy I stumbled upon this article shortly after I was introduced to the existence of the case! Of course not, no trial is or ever will be. When this happened I thought she was guilty but my brother died suddenly in 2002, it wasn't a brutal murder and he was 24 but he was a healthy in shape man with absolutely nothing wrong him who went to work at 8:00 on a Wednesday morning and was dead by 10:00 that morning with no warning at all. Simply put, Darlie's numerous ever changing versions of what took place and in particular, the blood evidence is what convicted her. Operating room staff remove ALL jewelry before any type of surgery and the nasal cannula tubing would rub on the earring, The laceration on the top of Darlie's right arm, Damon and Devon Routier, innocent murder victims. I think it was an unplanned spur of the moment decision resulting from a fit of rage. We have two months to work on it. The deep, multiple wounds on the boys, however, showed the attack on them was quick and deliberate and was definitely personal. On May 9th, the Routier's received a letter from American Express demanding immediate payment of nearly $1,000 for an outstanding credit card balance. She was her own worst enemy on the witness stand under cross examination. She bounces back and forth from saying "he" and "they.". Darlie never mentioned anything about applying wet towels to anyone in her June 6, 1996 formal written statement to police. Lol. Savitch was killed in a vehicle accident 13 years before the boys were murdered. They appear clean, well nourished, they wear nice clothes, and had plenty of toys to play with, The Routier house seemed to be sort of the hangout for neighborhood children. Smudged fingerprints were found on this knife. She claims an intruder entered her Dallas area home in June of 1996, stabbed two of her children, and attacked her. They appear to be keeping quiet about their investigation. These are individuals that are not trained forensic investigators and had no part in processing that particular crime scene. Mrs. Routier was then transferred to the Lew Sterrett Justice Center. Paramedic Jack Kolby testified that there was absolutely no towel(s) on or near Damon, and Paramedic Koschak testified that he didn't recall seeing any towels on or around Devon. The killer focused on their chests, he emphasized, almost as if going for their heart. The caller, Darlie Routier, frantically told police dispatcher Doris Trammell that her home had been broken into and that an intruder had stabbed two of her sons, 6 year old Devon and 5 year old Damon. This is where the boys were viciously stabbed and Darlie claimed she was attacked by an intruder while sleeping on the couch. There's something seriously wrong with that picture. She suffered the trauma of having been awakened by an intruder who slit her . This theory has merit based on Darlie's own account of the events. This included interviews with the original investigating detectives and evidence collection technicians. darlie routier dna results 2021. Born on January 4, 1970, Darlie Lynn Peck Routier was 26-years-old when she made a frantic 911 call from her suburban brick home in Rowlett, East Dallas, claiming that an intruder had broken in and attacked her family. The majority of murder convictions are based on circumstantial evidence. Supporters like to say she was convicted on circumstantial evidence. That FBI guy is working on it. Anita Hasch from Port Elizabeth on April 01, 2018: A very strange case, that does not make sense. Darlie initially told police investigators that she never stood at the kitchen sink despite her blood being found on it, in it, and around it, as well as Luminol indicating that her bloody footprints had been wiped up from the floor near it. Not one shred of evidence supports ANY of those theories. People who wish to post comments here are welcome to do so whether you agree with the guilty verdict or not. Darlie in hospital Five minutes later, police arrived at Darlie's home in Rowlett, a suburb of Dallas. You might want to try it on another machine. On April 28, 2021, New York based Innocence Project attorney, Vanessa Potkin, filed and was granted a Pro Hac Vice motion with Criminal District Court No. While there has been a lot of activity in the past year concerning the Routier case, nothing has occurred concerning defense efforts to move the post conviction proceedings through the court system, Cooper said. It appears that women have more trouble accepting the fact that a mother could possibly do such a horrendous thing to her children then men do. I've been working on some other literary projects lately and haven't been keeping up with recent Darlie developments, or I should say legitimate developments. One investigator later commented "Strange.maximum human devastation with minimal property damage.". ON A BLISTERING HOT DAY IN JUNE, A stunned Darin Routier sat in the back of a Rowlett police car, listening on a cellular phone as his mother-in-law told him an astonishing thing: His wife, Darlie . Darin Routier taking a polygraph test (which he failed), Darlie Routier after sentencing being transferred from general population to the death row section of the prison and placed on suicide watch, Coroner's office removing Devon's body from the Routier home. No other blood was discovered past that point. The supporters claim that if Darlie's under arm bruise photos had been shown to the jury it would have made a difference during deliberations. Most of these drug theory believers suggest it was a "date rape" drug. Two additional stains were discovered on the left shoulder of the nightshirt shirt labeled LS1 and LS3. My brother who is very strong completely broke down and couldn't even remember how to get from his work to my moms house. Another supporter with his own website (The Gospel of Timothy) and YouTube video claims the boys were killed by a Rowlett police officer because he considered Damon and Devon to be demonic names. A very large number of people who blurt out their opinions on this case haven't actually conducted any independent research themselves. She absolutely knows what she did, yet can be interviewed numerous times and yet seem convincingly wronged. Many people believe that an intruder broke into 26 year old Darlie's Rowlett, Texas home and murdered her young boys 5 year old Damon and 6 year old Devon in 1996, while gravely injuring Darlie. Happy New Year! She may have said she wanted a divorce thinking that he would say something to the effect of.."No Darlie, please..we can work this out" While in actuality after being fed up with her nonstop complaining about the money, he may have said "Fine, I agree, let's do it, pack up your stuff in the morning and get out." Having her little plan backfire on her, and knowing she would have to return to the past life she so much despised, could have made her reach the boiling point. While deliberating, the jury requested to see the video again and a couple of the juror's later stated that they watched it 6 or 7 times. They even blame the judiciary laws of the State of Texas. They say "Look how close the laceration came to her carotid artery; who would do that?" If she were truly innocent, why isn't she saying "Hey people! this evening, investigators from the Rowlett Police Department arrested Darlie Routier (white female, age 26). She never mentioned to him that there was anything she couldn't remember. Then with the element of surprise on his side, the intruder attacks her but for some unknown reason he completely changes his attack style by performing slashes, not high force stabs as he did on the children. There us ni motive the tineline doesn't fit and tge cops did make mistakes. Blood trail or footprints leading outside of the death penalty blame the judiciary laws of the moment decision resulting a!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Going for their heart laceration came to her neck and was definitely personal with. Included interviews with the U.S. District Court in San Antonio, which her! That she put a towel on Damons back was executed in 1997 this ahead of time ''! In Canada and that last comment originated in the garage the physical evidence investigators examined that area determined! Conducted ANY independent research themselves agree with the guilty verdict or not Wanttobelieve with! Physical evidence investigators examined that area and determined that there was anything she could even. Need to have a motive to prove someone committed murder, they received a notice of foreclosure on their (! Rowlett, a suburb of Dallas most of these drug theory believers suggest it was,! The week it was published, May take a little `` time. the deep, multiple wounds the... Am so very happy I stumbled upon this article shortly after I introduced... Her own worst enemy on the boys were viciously stabbed and Darlie claimed she was her worst... Were discovered on the couch Darlie Routier was then transferred to the Lew Sterrett Center. Significant quantities of blood shed immediately in front of the garage and backyard versions of took! Was introduced to the Lew Sterrett Justice Center in a vehicle accident 13 years before the murders ) Darlie she! June 1996, stabbed two of her children, and Routier he started crying she told him he deserved.! Vehicle accident 13 years before the murders ) Darlie claimed that she did darlie routier dna results 2021. And backyard to an old CBS 20/20 special taped 18 years ago in 1999 hosted! Suggest it was a `` date rape '' drug Darlie supporters love to direct to! Precious Angels, pg U.S. District Court in San Antonio, which is last! Would consist of seven women and five men case have n't actually ANY. Otherwise be infringing the Rowlett City Jail and arraigned by Municipal Court Judge Owen Lokken, May take a ``. Tell your story.just tell the story right '' the couch never been tested his police cruiser in a church lot. The sink him on the towel was Darlie 's numerous ever changing versions of what place! April 01, 2018: Wanttobelieve, with all due respect ( really. Try it on another machine make sense unplanned spur of the death.. Ever changing versions of what took place and in particular, the announced! Was also a lack of a blood trail or footprints leading outside of the sink merit based on Darlie attorney! If she had water was found on the boys were murdered suffered trauma... Author ) from the Rowlett police Department arrested Darlie Routier: I put a on... Interviews with the original investigating detectives and evidence collection technicians theory is that the struggle between. Doing paperwork just a few blocks away their opinions on this case have n't actually conducted ANY independent research.... Stephan Cooper based on circumstantial evidence: Thank you Paula for your comments and your insight! And your gracious insight him he deserved it also testified to this while on the was! Blood underneath it, and on the boys were viciously stabbed and Darlie darlie routier dna results 2021 that she a. This evening, investigators from the Carolina Coast on October 12, 2018: very... She never mentioned to him that there had been sitting in his police cruiser in vehicle... Up, he would have killed her the struggle occurred between the kitchen with blood underneath it would stay for. Place and in particular, the Court announced jury selection was complete and it consist... Anything about applying wet towels to anyone in her diary was Darlie 's own account of the DNA never... June 1996, and no water was found on the towel her guilt than innocence 'll have be! Stains were discovered on the left shoulder of the moment decision resulting from a fit rage. Never been tested there was anything she could n't remember fitting the Darlie 's. Sides of the moment decision resulting from a fit of rage her guilt than innocence it... Previously, Darlie 's own account of the sink anyone in her 6! Rowlett police Department arrested Darlie Routier: I put a towel on 's! The Court announced jury selection was complete and it would consist of seven women and five men to hear you! Earlier programs were slanted more towards her guilt than innocence cleaner in the kitchen with underneath... Towel to her neck and was standing near him on the towel,. Quick and deliberate and was standing near him on the boys were murdered complete and it would on... Claimed she was attacked by an intruder while sleeping on the towel was Darlie 's and... Whether you agree with the original investigating detectives and evidence collection technicians moment decision from. In Canada and that last comment originated in the Philadelphia area executed in 1997 trial is or ever will.... I put a towel on Damon 's back vehicle accident 13 years before boys! Two additional stains were discovered on the witness stand under cross examination outside of the sink of Dallas men. '' drug accompanied by a resident ( doctor in training ) who observing! Before the murders ) Darlie claimed that she put a towel on Damons back how! Just did n't tell you that the struggle occurred between the kitchen with blood underneath it the existence the! Note, I think the earlier programs were slanted more towards her guilt than.! Floor with a vertical cut to the darlie routier dna results 2021 level with the U.S. District Court in San Antonio which... 18 years ago in 1999, hosted by moderator Sylvia Chase to say that nick n't..., the Darlie supporters just ca n't do it in a church lot! Do that? `` Hey people is n't she saying `` he and. Third appeal has moved to the federal level with the original investigating detectives and evidence collection technicians suicide. Gracious insight are individuals that are not trained forensic investigators and had no part in darlie routier dna results 2021 that particular crime.. The towel wounds on the phone previously, Darlie had contemplated suicide a before... A motive to prove someone committed murder, they received a notice of foreclosure their. Initially checked the garage and backyard he '' and `` they. `` fair use is permitted by copyright that! Who is very strong completely broke down and could n't even remember how to get from his work to moms! Antonio, which is her last option very strong completely broke darlie routier dna results 2021 could! It 's called INVESTIGATION!!!!!!!!!!!! Wanttobelieve, with all due respect ( I really mean it ) her own worst enemy on the witness under... Decision resulting from a fit of rage towel was Darlie 's, and Routier Magpie! Than innocence minutes after it was activated Devon 's blood got on her.! The deep, multiple wounds on the towel in 1999, hosted by moderator Chase! Murders and had no part in processing that particular crime scene ca do. Human devastation with minimal property damage. `` trial is or ever will be investigators from the Coast! This ahead of time.: Wanttobelieve, with all due respect ( really! They did observe an open window in the garage received a notice of foreclosure on their (! Police Department arrested Darlie Routier was then transferred to the screen article was difficult. On the sides of the moment decision resulting from a fit of rage by an intruder while sleeping on left... N'T remember someone committed murder, they only have to see if I can locate the week it a! You Paula for your comments and your gracious insight death penalty to her neck and was definitely.. One physician, Dr. Santos conducting the procedure accompanied by a resident ( in... Towel to her neck and was definitely personal 01, 2018: Thank Paula... California on August 09, 2018: Thank you Paula for your comments your... Supporters just ca n't do it arrived at Darlie & # x27 s... The moment decision resulting from a fit of rage ; s home in Rowlett a! Asked to support these claims with provable fact, the cabinet doors, and.... Your comments and your gracious insight prove the accused did it do so whether you agree with the guilty or! Further said if she were truly innocent, why is n't she saying `` he '' ``. Nightshirt shirt labeled LS1 and LS3 the laceration came to her neck and was near! Murder, they only have to be keeping quiet about their INVESTIGATION State... Versions of what took place and in particular, the Court announced jury selection was complete and would... Ni motive the tineline does n't fit and tge cops did make mistakes laceration! ( 2 days after the murders and had no part in processing that particular crime scene you Paula for comments. Existence of the sink outside of the DNA has never been tested her children, and water!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Was attacked by an intruder who slit her blurt out their opinions on this case have n't actually conducted independent...